Citation
Beyond the valley

Material Information

Title:
Beyond the valley In the aftermath of the quake, there is a need to follow the people, not just the flattened buildings
Added title page title:
In the aftermath of the quake, there is a need to follow the people, not just the flattened buildings
Creator:
Bevan, John ( Author, Primary )
Place of Publication:
Kathmandu
Publisher:
The Kathmandu Post
Publication Date:
Copyright Date:
© 2015, Kantipur Digital Corp
Language:
English

Subjects

Subjects / Keywords:
Earthquake impacts ( SWAY )
Earthquake damage ( LCSH )
भूकम्पका प्रभावहरु ( SWAY )
Displacement ( SWAY )
Refugees ( LCSH )
विस्थापन ( SWAY )
Infrastructure ( SWAY )
Infrastructure (Economics) ( LCSH )
पूर्वाधारहरु ( SWAY )
Roads ( SWAY )
Roads ( LCSH )
सडकहरु ( SWAY )
Rescue and relief ( SWAY )
Disaster relief ( LCSH )
Rescues ( LCSH )
उद्धार तथा राहत ( SWAY )
Economic impacts ( SWAY )
Economic impact analysis ( LCSH )
आर्थिक प्रभाव ( SWAY )
Genre:
Newspaper op-ed ( SWAY )
Temporal Coverage:
20150425 - 20150520
Spatial Coverage:
Asia -- Nepal
Coordinates:
28 x 84

Notes

General Note:
Published in: The Kathmandu Post (© 2015, Khatmandu Post) -- http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/news/2015-05-20/beyond-the-valley.html
General Note:
एशिया -- नेपाल
General Note:
Asie -- Népal

Record Information

Source Institution:
SOAS University of London
Rights Management:
© 2015, Khatmandu Post
Resource Identifier:
SP150520A1 ( SWAY )

Downloads

This item has the following downloads:


Full Text
01/08/2017

Beyond the Valley - Oped - The Kathmandu Post

(http:,

/ /d«ction.dcantipiir.oom/?lng=€!ng)
OPED (/CATEGORY/OPED)

Beyond the Valley

In the aftermath of the quake, there is a need to follow the people, not just the flattened buildings

- JoHN Sevan lyauthor/john+bevan}

0 f -

SHARES

May 20, 2015-

Th e obvious visible impact of a quake is the destruction of buildings. It is not surprising that journalists, donors, and governments alike become hypnotised
by broken buildings, but this hides the multitude of other impacts, such as the displacement of people.

Haiti, lost opportunity

In Haiti, some 600,000 people fled the devastated capital, according to the tracking of mobile phones by some foreign students. Most probably went to their
parental homes in villages; others just anywhere other than the hell of Port-au-Prince (PauP). Their departure was a real blessing to PauP, whose
infrastructure has been overwhelmed since the introduction of assembly plants in the 1970s. Yet, nothing was done to encourage these people to remain
'outside', as they say in Haiti. I suspect that a small amount of money, tiny given the oceans of dollars swishing around PauP, could have provided an incentive
to stay in the provinces.Instead 'cash for work' (what is work other than for cash? Slavery?)programmes in PauP actually attracted new rural dwellers into the
capital—so PauP soon returned to its bloated self and the next opportunity to 'decentralise', the stated aim of successive governments, -will cost a whole lot

Donors and governments tend to want to spend money where the ruins are, and identifying the location of the victims who own those ruins is much more
complicated. Someone who lost their house in PauP pretty much lost their chance of compensation or aidby not remaining next to their rubble with an
outstretched hand.

Outside Kathiuaondu

The Nepal quake had much, much less impact on its capital than its Haitian predecessor. While international media coverage went overboard on the sad sights
of beautiful pagoda temples in ruins, distorting the real impact of the quake on poor peasants on a vast arc of the mid-hill areas to the north of Kathmandu, it
was accurate to the extent that few new buildings fell while old brick monuments and housing crumbled. It is almost possible to drive across the town and not
really spot that there has been a quake—the damage could be construed as redevelopment of old sites for new building. And Sindhupalchowk, a relatively small
rural district, ended up having lost many more souls than the Capital.But by the end of week one, it had received barely any aid. And 'access' is not an excuse
anymore than it is in the eight worst-hit districts—Sindhupalchowkis about three hours away from Kathmandu on a good road. Of course, like most hill
districts, there are many hamlets that have no road and so,are a long walk from even their own main town. And even fewer wards are more than a couple of
hours walk from a potential helicopter landing zone.

Nonetheless, the media is reporting that hundreds of thousands have left Kathmandu. This means losing income—part of which would have been sent back to
the families and communities upon whom they are now dependent, an extra mouth to feed in places where there is little to spare.

Reviving Rautahat?

http: / /kathmandupos t. ekantipur. com/ news /2015-05-20/beyond- the- vail ey. html

1/4


01/08/2017 Beyond the Valley - Oped - The Kathmandu Post

I was particularly struck by one newspaper report that 10,000 people had 'gone back' to Rautahat district, which the 2014 Human Development Report reveals
to be one of the most deprived. Noone calls them Internally Displaced People (IDPs), but that is what they are. If you are forced from your 'habitual' residence
by disaster, natural or human, you are an IDP wherever you go inside the country, whether you move a few yards to your home village. Rautahat, like one or
two other places I have seen to, appears to have little to recommend it; in fact, it appears to have little at all. It was the scene in 2007 of one of the worst
incidents of violence, when 27 Maoist cadres were hacked to death by who knows who. It's the sort of place that makes you realise why working on a chain gang
for the 2020 World Cup could look attractive, even for a pittance and condemnation to migrant labour barracks—and plenty of young people in their prime
have made that move. And now 10,000 are reported to have voluntarily returned from a Kathmandu that was clearly reviving within a few days of the quake.

This displacement really is an 'opportunity', but so far, there is no sign of anyone—donor, NGO, or ministry—giving it a moment's thought. Ten or twenty
thousand dollars could transform Gaur, the district capital, from nothing to something. And potentially reducing the population of overcrowded Kathmandu by
say 10 toi5 percent would make the Capital lessunmanageable.

Whole picture

But no, let's get back to the collapsed buildings—that's where the action is. Odd.

Perhaps this is just another symptom of the psychological impact of a quake on decision makers. The first thing that breaks after the quake is the ability of the
governing class to take decisions, for a variety of reasons, from poor communications to trauma. Participation, planning, and inclusion lie forlorn in a pile but
unlike the rubble, they are invisible.

It took a long time for Post Traumatic Stress Disorder to be recognised as a real thing—now for the other overlooked consequences of big natural disasters.
Let's look at the whole picture, not exclusively the rubble and dust.

Bevan worked for the UN in Nepal in 2003/4 and 2006/7. He also worked in Haiti both before and after the 2010 earthquake

Published: 20-05-2015 07:24 | ]

The Kathmandu Post (/) > Oped (/category/oped) > John Bevan (/author/john+bevan)

NEXT STORY

Slipping and sliding (/news/2015-05- >
20/slipping-and-sliding.html)

Tags: John Bevan (/Tag/John+Bevan)

User's Feedback

Click here for your comments

Comment via Facebook

0 Comments

Add a comment...

Facebook Comments Plugin

Don't have facebook account? Use this form to comment

Loading...

MORE FROM OPED (/CATEGORY/OPED)

(/news/2017

08-
01/healthy-

young-
minds.html)

Healthy young minds
(/news/2017-08-
o 1 /healthy-young-
minds, html)

Aug 01, 2017-

No water, no life
(/news/20i7-o8-oi/no-
water-no-life .html)

(/news/2017 Aug 01,2017-
08-0l/n0-
water-no-
life.html)

full story » (/news/20i7-o8-oi/no-water-no-
life.html)

Shining light
(/news/2017-08-
01/shi ning-light.html)

(/news/2017 Aug 01, 2017-

08-
01/shining-
light.html)

full story » (/news/20i7-08-0i/shining-light.html)

Sort by Oldest

http: //kathmandupost. ekantipur. com/news/2015-05-20/beyond-the-valley. html

2/4


01/08/2017

Beyond the Valley - Oped - The Kathmandu Post

full story » (/news/20i7-o8-oi/healthy-young-
minds.html)

Health insurance
intricacies (/news/2017-
(/news/2017 07-30/health-insurance-

07-
30/health-
insurance-
intricacies.hl

full story » (/news/20i7-07-30/health-insurance-
intricacies.html)

intricacies .html)
Jul 30,2017-

The Macron era
(/news/20i7-08-0i/the-
macron-era.html)
(/news/2017 Aug Ol, 2017-
08-0l/the-
macron-
era.html)
full story » (/news/20i7-o8-oi/the-macron-
era.html)

The fight against
trafficking in persons
(/^w^ (/news/2017-07-3 o/the-

oy-so/the-
fight-
against-
trafficking-
in-

persons.htm

full story » (/news/20i7-07-30/the-fight-against-
trafficking-in-persons.html)

fight-against-trafficking-
in-persons.html)

Jul 30, 2017-

(/news/2017

07"
31/remembe
ambedkar-

Remembering Ambedkar
in Bangalore (/news/2017-
07-31/ remembering-
ambedkar-in-
bangalore.html)
Jul 31, 2017-

m-

bangalore.ht

full story » (/news/20i7-07-3i/remembering-
ambedkar-in-bangalore.html)

^^ _ Doklam stand-off and

tQ L§| Nepal (/news/2017-07-
^^ ^ 3o/doklam-stand-off-and-

(/news/2017 nePal-html)

07- Jul 30, 2017-
30/doklam-
stand-off-

and-
nepal.html)

full story » (/news/20i7-07-3o/doklam-stand-off-
and-nepal.html)

»I Leave nature alone

(/news/20i7-07-30/leave-
^mmt^tS^M nature-alone.html)
(/news/2017

07_ Jul 30, 2017-

30/leave-
nature-
alone.html)

full story » (/news/20i7-07-30/leave-nature-
alone.html)

Case for deliberative polls
(/news/20i7-07-28/case-
for-deliberative-
(/news/2017 polls.html)
07-28/case- Jul28

,2017-

for-
deliberative-
polls.html)

full story » (/news/20i7-07-28/case-for-
deliberative-polls.html)

TRENDING

t

I'*"

Agreement reached to rebuild Dharahara in a 'mixed style' (http://bit.ly/2tUr4Vd)

full stoiy » (http://bit.ly/2tUr4Vd)

90th PLA day marked in Capital (http://bit.ly/2tTwXSE)

full stoiy » (http://bit.ly/2tTwXSE)

13 years on, nat'l pride project still incomplete

(http://kathmandup0st.ekantipur.c0m/news/2017-08-01/13-years-0n-natl-pride-pr0ject-still-
incomplete.html)

full story » (http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/news/2017-08-01/13-years-on-natl-pride-project-still-incomplete.html)



Nepal, China trade set to normalise soon (http://kathmandup0st.ekantipur.c0m/news/2017-08-
01/nepal-china-trade-set-to-normalise-soon .html)
(http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/news/2017-08-01/nepal-china-trade-set-to-normalise-soon.html)

Top Indian and Chinese officials arriving (http://bit.ly/2tUhba3)

full stoiy » (http://bit.ly/2tUhba3)

L

Kavre grappling with rising cases of suicide (http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/news/2017-
o8-oi/kavre-grappling-with-rising-cases-of-suicide.html)
full story » (http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.eom/news/2017-08-01/kavre-grappling-with-rising-cases-of-suicide.html)

http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/news/2015-05-20/beyond-the-valley.html

3/4


01/08/2017

•L •' H w J u
P \ ^HUA

Beyond the Valley - Oped - The Kathmandu Post

m

J fi j

The Macron era (http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/news/2017- o&-oi/the-macron-era.html)
full story » [http://kathmandupo3t.ekantipur.com/new3/2017-0 8-0 l/ihe-macron-era.html}

Team Nepal leaves for int'l debate championship

(http: //kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/ news/ 2017-0 8- 01/team-nepal-leaves-fbr-intl-debate-
championship .html)

full story » [http://kathmandu pratekantipur .com/news/ 2017-0 S-0 l/team-nepal-leaves-for-intl-debate-championship.html}

Pregnant rhino died of'anthrax' in GtfP (htip://katbmandupost.ekantipur.com/news/2 017-08-
01/ pregnant-rhino-died-of-anthrax-in-mp.html)
full story » [http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/nevra/2017-0B-01/pregnant-rhino-died-of-anthrax-in-cnp.html}

Illegal tenants to be evicted from industrial estate site

(http:/ /kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/nevts/ 2017-0&-0 l/illegal-tenants-to-be-evicted-from-
industri al -estate-si te html)
landupost.elantipur .com/nevra / 2 017-0S-01 /ille^l-ten ants-to-be-evicted-from-industiial-estatE-site.html}

MAIN NEWS

Cooking gas cheaper by Rs 25 per cylinder (http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/news/ 2017-
08-01/ cooking-gas-cheaper-by-rs-25-per-cylinder.html)
Aug 01,2017-

(http:/ /kathmandupost ekantipur.com/nevts/ 20i7-oS-oi/cooking-gas-che^er-by-rs-25-peiMylinder.html)

full story » [http:/Zte1thmandupo3t.ekantipur.com/new3/20i7-08-0i/cra

SC orders judicial remand of Chudamani Sharma

(http:/ /kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/news/ 2017-08- oi/sc-ordeis-judicial-remand-of-
chudamani-sharma.html)

(http://kathmandupost ekantipur.com/nevts/ 2017-0S-01/sc-onfleis-judicial-remand-of-chiidamani^harma.html) OL'2017

full story » [http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/news/2017-0B-01/sc-arders-judicial-remand-of--chudamani-5harma.html}

L^y

PlffigH

Cancelled ballots of Bharatpur Metropolis-19 destroyed

(http: //kathmandupost.ekantipur. com/news/ 2 017-08-01/ cancelled-ballots-of-

bharatpur^metropoli s-19-destrojed.html)

Aug 01,2017-

(http:/ /kathmandupost ekantipur.com/nevts/ 2017-0&-0 VcanceUed-baUots-of-bharatpur-metiopolis-19-d^troyedhtml)

full story » [http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/news/2017-0 B-0 l/canceUed-baUota-of-bharatpur-me tropoHs-l^-destroyed.html}

Re-election in Bharatpur Metropolis-19 slated for August 4 (http://katfjmandupost.ekantipur.com/news/2 017-08-01/re-dection-in-bharatp11r-metropolis-19-on-augLKt-4.html)
Aug 01, 2017-

fullstory » [http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/nevra/2017-0B-Ol/re-election-in-bharatpur-metiopolis-l^-on-august-^.html}

Nepal's poli Mahara (http: //kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/ news/ 2017- oS-
oi/nepals-poUcy-is-to-maintain-close-ties-with-india-china-dpm-
W MIH \ mahaia.html)

(http:/ /kathmandupost ekantipur.com/nevts/ 2017-08-01/ nepals-poHcy-is-to-maintaon-dose-tie^ ^

full story » [http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/nevra/2017-0B-Ol/nepals-pohcy-is-to-maintain-cla5e-ties-V1dth-india-china-dpm-mahara.html}

Agreement reached to rebuild Dharahara in a 'mixed style'
(http:/ /kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/news/ 2017-08-01/a^eement-reached-
to-rebuild-dhaiahaia-in-a-mixed-style html)

(http://kathmandupost ekantipur.com/nevts/ 2017-0S-01/agmement-reached-to-rebuild-dharahara-in-a-mixed-stjdehtml) OL'2017

full story » [http://kathmandupost.ekantipur .com/news/2 017-0 S-0 l/^greement-reached-to-rebuild-dharahara-in-a-mixed-5iyle.html}

1

v

V

' 1

M

Top Indian and Chinese officials arriving (http://kathmandup0st.ekantipur.e0m/news/2017-08-
01/ top-indian-and-chinese-offitials-arriving.html)
Aug 01,2017-

(http:/ /kathmandupost ekantipur.com/nevts/ 2017-oS-oi/top-indian-and-chin^-officials-arriving.html)

full story » [http: //kathmandupo3t.ekantipur.com/news/2017-0 8-0 l/top-indian-and-chinese-officials-arri'nng.html}

Man interrupts Health Minister's speech to question govt's cost-free medicines policy (http://katfjmandupost.ekarjtipur.com/news/2 017- oS-oi/man-intern^ts-health-ministers-speech-to-question-govts-

cost-ftee-medicines-policy.html)

Aug 01,2017-

full story » [http://kathmandupostekantipur .com/nevra/2017-0S-0l/man-interrupts-health-mirusters-speech-to^uestion-go-43-cost-free-medicines-pdicy.html}

3 injured as truck plunges off Dhading's Hugdi Khola bridge

(http: //katfimandup ost.ekantipur.com/ news/ 2017- 08-01/3-injured-as-truck-plunges-
off-hugdi-khola-bridgehtml)

(http://kathmandupost ekantipur.com/nevts/ 2017-08-01/3-injured-as-truck-plunges-0ff-hugdi-kh0la-bridge.html) 01,2 017

full story » [http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/news/2017-0S-0l/3-injured-as-truck-plunges-off-hugdi-khola-bridge.html}

m



13 years on, nat'l pride project still incomplete

(http:/ /kathmandupost. ekantipur.com/nevts/ 2017-08-01/ 13-years-on-natl-pride-project-
still-incomplete.html)

(http://kathmandupost ekantipur.com/nevts/ 2017-0S-01/13-j
full story » (http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/news/2017-OS-01/ i3-year3-on-nati-pride-project-3till-incomplete.html}

The Katlmandu Pott'« Categories

http: / /kathmandupos t. ekantipur. com / news /2015-05-20/beyond- the- vail ey. html

4/4


Full Text